What “Vincent and the Doctor” Means to Me

(This post comes with a trigger warning for mentions of depression, suicide and mental illnesses.)

“It’s so clear you cannot help. And when you leave, and everyone always leaves, I will be left once more with an empty heart and no hope.”

Vincent van Gogh standing in a field at night in wool coat, Amy Pond wearing blue coat looking at the artist sadly and thoughtfully. The Doctor's back is turned.

Vincent van Gogh and Amy Pond (Image via BBC)

I first watched Doctor Who episode “Vincent and the Doctor” (5.10) in March of 2012 at the absolute peak of a depressive episode, one of the worst I’ve had to date. I was stressed, suicidal, and considering dropping out of college just two months shy of graduation. Between two jobs, I was working almost 30 hours a week and had anxiety attacks in the middle of class. My seething self-loathing and inability to get out of bed was accompanied by insomnia. Thinking about that time in my life is triggering to me and even now as I type this out, I’m fighting back tears. I haven’t watched “Vincent and the Doctor” since and I probably never will again, but the episode still has left a lasting impression.

I had started the fifth season of Doctor Who during that depressive episode. Because I couldn’t sleep and I was too sad to do any work for school, curling into my quilt in the dark with Netflix on my laptop seemed like the best course of action. As annoyed as I was by Matt Smith’s existence (I’m an Eccleston girl), the episode had my attention from the beginning. Bill Nighy (in an uncredited role) as a museum curator and Van Gogh fanboy? Yes please and thank you very much! And when I realized that the Doctor and Amy were going to see Vincent Van Gogh, I found myself perking up for the first time in weeks. Van Gogh? About damn time Moffat!

The episode starts out with the Doctor and Amy visiting Paris’s Musée d’Orsay, where they spot a mysterious figure in one of Vincent Van Gogh’s paintings, one that the Doctor thinks doesn’t belong there. They travel to the 19th century where they meet Van Gogh, played by Tony Curran, and they set about solving the mystery. Instead of poking fun at Van Gogh’s mental state, Curran gave an honest portrayal of mental illness. (Although, there are a multitude of theories as to what mental conditions Van Gogh suffered from). I found something incredibly beautiful and raw about Curran’s Van Gogh; I was transfixed. The sniffles had started by the scene when Van Gogh wandered to his window to look down into the yard to see Amy surrounded by sunflowers she gathered, hoping to inspire the artist. I watched the episode through Van Gogh’s eyes, especially when he began describing the pain of his loneliness and his fear of abandonment.

Amy Pond wearing a red sweater is smiling sitting in a yard filled with pots of sunflowers

“I thought you might like, you know, possibly to perhaps… paint them, or something? Might be a thought.” (Image via Screened.com)

The last ten minutes of “Vincent and the Doctor” were emotionally devastating for me. Van Gogh, in an attempt to protect himself and his new friends, kills the monster, which only he can see. It’s only as the creature lays dying that the Doctor learns it’s in fact an abandoned young alien. The pain on Van Gogh’s face, as he realized what he’s done, left me sobbing to the point of an anxiety attack, but with my ever growing pile of tissues I soldiered on.

The hardest part of “Vincent and the Doctor” is knowing Van Gogh’s history. At the end of the episode, the Doctor and Amy bring Van Gogh to his exhibition at the Musée d’Orsay and there he seems like a changed man. He hears curator Mr. Black (Billy Nighy) say that Van Gogh is “the greatest painter of them all” and “one of the greatest men who ever lived.” The emotion on Van Gogh’s face is overwhelming and Amy is convinced that Van Gogh’s life will change for the better. Sadly, as we and the Doctor know, this is far from the case. Vincent Van Gogh would commit suicide at the age of 37, one year after he was introduced to Amy.

A close up of Vincent van Gogh's face, crying. Behind him stands museum curator wearing bow tie, tweed jacket, and the Doctor and Amy with their backs turned

Van Gogh listening to Mr. Black’s praise. (Image via Inside Trekker)

I don’t know when I would have come out of my depressed state if I hadn’t seen “Vincent and the Doctor.” I woke up the next morning feeling energized. For the first time in weeks I felt like a functioning human being again who could do normal human things like go to work and class, read, and take a shower. I needed this episode as a person who struggles with depression and as an active consumer of popular media. Mental illness tends to be less than visible within the realm of pop culture, and when such characters are represented, they are often scapegoated and one dimensional, with the horror genre being one of the most blatant examples of that. This poor representation is especially problematic when we consider statistics. As reported by the National Alliance on Mental Health, “one in four adults – approximately 61.5 million Americans – experiences mental illness in a given year” and about 13.6 million people “live with a serious mental illness such as schizophrenia, major depression, or bipolar disorder”. (PDF) This is exactly why we need honest portrayals of mental illness in our popular culture. “Vincent and the Doctor” manages to do what is so often amiss, by reminding us that Vincent van Gogh, and by extension all individuals with mental illness, are human beings and not just some plot twist or side story.

About Krista

Krista is a proud cat enthusiast who spends a majority of their free time crafting and watching horror films, with occasional breaks for DC cartoons. They earned their MA in Popular Culture at BGSU and a BA in history from UW-Green Bay. They are currently in school again for a secondary education license. Their primary focuses are queer identity and mental illness representation in television and film.
This entry was posted in guest post and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to What “Vincent and the Doctor” Means to Me

  1. Mark says:

    That’s a beautiful insight into a beautiful episode.

  2. Mariana says:

    I found your post while searching for an picture of this episode to post on Facebook how deep it took on me. Your text just amplified that feeling. It is a very, very beautiful episode and the aknowledge in the end, at the gallery, that really was something. I’m somehow glad to ser that there’s other people sharing this feeling with me. Thanks, Krista.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.